Where We Fish

Fishing Guide in Key Colony Beach

Fishing near Key Colony Beach offers a taste of the Keys' best, with opportunities for both inshore and offshore action.

On the Water

Fishing Key Colony Beach

Key Colony Beach sits right in the heart of the Florida Keys, giving us access to a variety of fishing grounds. We can head out to the offshore reefs and wrecks for bottom dwellers like Grouper and Snapper, or chase pelagic species like Mahi Mahi and Wahoo when they're running. For those looking for a true Keys challenge, Tarpon fishing is often excellent in the channels and nearshore structures. The bite here changes with the seasons; spring and fall are prime for Tarpon and offshore migrations, while summer brings consistent action on reef fish and opportunistic pelagics. A charter out of Key Colony Beach means we’re minutes from the fishing grounds, maximizing your time on the water.

Trip Options

4 hours
$850/ trip

Reef Fishing

All bait, tackle, and gear provided Up to 6 guests per boat Licensed & insured captain Great for all experience levels

  • Up to 5 anglers
6 hours
$1,000/ trip

Reef & Wreck Fishing

All bait, tackle, and gear provided Up to 6 guests per boat Licensed & insured captain Great for all experience levels

  • Up to 5 anglers
4 hours
$600/ trip

Sunset Cruise, Snorkeling, Sandbar Trips

Great calm family fun sunset trips, snorkeling or hanging out on the sandbar!

6 hours
$1,250/ trip

Offshore Fishing

All bait, tackle, and gear provided Up to 6 guests per boat Licensed & insured captain Great for all experience levels

  • Up to 5 anglers
8 hours
$1,500/ trip

Full Day

All bait, tackle, and gear provided Up to 6 guests per boat Licensed & insured captain Great for all experience levels

  • Up to 5 anglers

Important information

What We Provide

  • A boat rigged and ready for the day's fishing
  • Rods, reels, and tackle for every angler
  • All bait, ice, and terminal tackle
  • Your fishing license for the day
  • Bottled water and cold drinks
  • A licensed captain who knows the water

What to Bring

  • Sunglasses, sunscreen & a hat
  • Food and drinks in a soft cooler
  • Weather-appropriate clothing and a light jacket
  • Non-marking, closed-toe shoes
  • Your camera — and a sense of adventure
Have a custom trip in mind? Call and we'll set it up.

Fishing Key Colony Beach with Jersey Key Charters

Local Knowledge

We know Marathon waters and how the bite changes with the season and conditions.

On the Water Daily

Based in Marathon and running trips all season long.

All Experience Levels

From first-timers and kids to seasoned anglers, we tailor the trip to your crew.

4.9★ Google Rating

Rated 4.9 out of 5 on Google from 119 reviews.

Rated 4.9 stars on Google

What Anglers Say

“Captain Mike is the real deal. He and 1st mate, are down to earth, hardworking and dedicated to putting you on fish. Been on a lot of charters over my years, and I recommend them highly. From booking to departure, top class operation.”
Scott Wilson - Best Shot Insurance
Verified Google Review
“We had an outstanding trip with Jersey Key Charters! Captain Mike was knowledgeable, professional, and worked hard from start to finish to put us on fish. He knew exactly where to go and was great at explaining what we were targeting and how to fish each spot. Whether you’re an…”
Ian Burnett
“Captain Mike provided an awesome experience on the water! We got on the fish quickly, and he was fantastic with the kids, making the trip fun and memorable for everyone. He was knowledgeable, patient, and worked hard to keep us on the bite. I highly recommend booking a charter…”
Steve Dias
“What a great day with Captain Mike! He is an expert on Mutton Fishing and so much more. We will definitely be chartering him again! A fantastic day.”
Kristi Gomen
“Did an offshore trip with Capt. Mike and had a great time. Capt. Mike is such a nice guy to be around, and he knows how to fish. I will always book with Jersey Key charters when I am in the keys. We caught amberjack, mahi mahi and the icing on the cake was mutton snapper. Thx…”
Gary Kraayenbrink
“Great Captain - full support without stealing the show from the fish. My 13 year old was thrilled.”
Laura Blair

Fishing Key Colony Beach FAQ

What species can I expect to catch near Key Colony Beach?
Near Key Colony Beach, we commonly target Tarpon, Mahi Mahi, Grouper, Wahoo, Tuna, Snapper, Sailfish, and Cobia, depending on the season and where we fish.
Is Key Colony Beach good for Tarpon fishing?
Yes, the waters around Key Colony Beach are known for Tarpon, especially during their migratory seasons in spring and fall. We often find them nearshore and in channels.
What's the best time of year for offshore fishing from Key Colony Beach?
For offshore species like Mahi Mahi and Wahoo, spring through fall often provides the best opportunities, with migratory patterns dictating peak times.
Book your trip with Jersey Key Charters today.

Ready to Get on the Water?

Dates fill up fast in season. Reach out to Jersey Key Charters to lock in your charter.

Photo from Jersey Key Charters